In the United States, the exact number of incarcerated women who give birth each year remains unclear. However, organizations such as the ACLU estimate that approximately 4% of the over 200,000 women entering jails and prisons annually are pregnant. Amy Johnson, deputy director of the ACLU’s National Prison Project, suggests that this translates to thousands of births. A 2010 report from the American Journal of Nursing noted that around 6% of women in jails are pregnant.
The Lack of Systematic Data
Carolyn Sufrin, the author of “Jailcare: Finding the Safety Net for Women Behind Bars,” highlights the lack of systematic data on the reproductive experiences of incarcerated women. The only substantial data available comes from a 1997 survey conducted by the American Correctional Association, which indicated 1,400 births across 47 state prison systems. There is no comprehensive information regarding miscarriages, abortions, or stillbirths among this population, revealing a significant gap in vital statistics.
The Alarming Reality of Shackling
One alarming reality is that many states still permit the shackling of women during childbirth. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists defines shackling as using physical restraints such as handcuffs or leg irons to restrict the movement of a prisoner. This practice is condemned by various organizations, including Amnesty International and the Federal Bureau of Prisons. In March 2018, North Carolina became one of the few states to prohibit it, while eight states—Utah, Kansas, Nebraska, South Carolina, Indiana, Maryland, Georgia, and Maine—have no regulations against it. Furthermore, 20 states may ban shackling only during childbirth but allow it during transport or postpartum recovery.
Even in states where shackling is officially banned, violations persist. A 2015 survey by the Correctional Association of New York revealed that 23 out of 27 surveyed women gave birth while restrained, despite the state’s ban.
The Contrast of Experiences
Consider your own experience with labor and delivery. You likely recall the freedom of movement, the support of loved ones, and the various positions you adopted during the process. These experiences starkly contrast with those of women who are shackled. For instance, Sarah Mitchell, who gave birth in New York in 2013—two years after the state’s shackling ban—was restrained during transport to the hospital and was denied the opportunity to contact her family.
Similarly, Emma Rodriguez experienced wrist and ankle restraints during childbirth despite the existing ban. She described being handcuffed to the hospital bed, which severely limited her ability to move and push during delivery. Jessica Brown endured painful shackling during her labor in Wisconsin, where no anti-shackling laws exist; she was left in severe pain because the restraints hindered the effectiveness of her epidural.
The Health Risks of Shackling
Shackling not only strips women of their dignity but also poses significant health risks. Restraints can prevent women from reacting adequately during labor, increasing pain and complicating the childbirth process. Postpartum, shackled women are at a heightened risk of developing blood clots due to restricted movement. Tragically, in emergencies, medical staff must wait for guards to remove restraints before they can provide critical care.
Defending Shackling Practices
Some law enforcement officials defend shackling as a necessary precaution, citing concerns over the potential for violence from inmates, regardless of their condition. A spokesperson for the state prison system asserted that even pregnant women are still convicted felons and may pose a threat to hospital staff during delivery.
The Societal Implications
The persistence of this practice highlights a disturbing reality about how society views pregnant women in prison. The physical and emotional toll of labor is profound, and shackling diminishes the humanity of the experience. Dr. Carolyn Sufrin, an expert in correctional health care, emphasizes the degrading nature of this practice and its detrimental effects on the health and well-being of incarcerated women.
The Call for Change
It is imperative that shackling during childbirth be abolished nationwide. No woman should have to endure the indignity of giving birth in chains, and no child should enter the world under such conditions.
For those interested in pregnancy and home insemination, you may find helpful resources at IVF Babble, or explore methods to boost fertility at Make a Mom. Additionally, future dads can find valuable insights on enhancing male fertility at Intracervical Insemination.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the practice of shackling women during childbirth in American prisons represents a significant violation of human rights and dignity. It is essential to advocate for the end of such practices to ensure a compassionate and humane approach to childbirth for all women.