In a bold move, Chicago Public Schools (CPS) has announced that starting with the class of 2020, students will not receive their high school diplomas unless they provide proof of a post-graduation plan. These plans can include acceptance to college, enrollment in the military, or job offers. While dubbed a motivational initiative aimed at encouraging students to think seriously about their futures, this requirement raises significant concerns about equity and accessibility.
Mayor Tom Richards, who champions the initiative under the Learn, Plan, Succeed program, believes that setting higher expectations will motivate students. “We’re here to ensure that kids have a plan because it’s essential for their success,” he said during the announcement. The intended goal is clear: to encourage seniors to actively pursue opportunities beyond high school. However, this approach overlooks critical factors such as socio-economic status, race, and geographic location, all of which can heavily influence a student’s options and opportunities.
As journalist Clara Johnson from The Insight highlighted, this mandate could disproportionately impact marginalized students. For many, college is financially out of reach, and the costs associated with applications can be prohibitive. Consequently, these students might find themselves pushed toward military service—a path already taken by a significant number of underprivileged youths. The reality is that securing employment is also a challenging endeavor, especially in communities where job opportunities are scarce.
Moreover, the initiative raises practical concerns regarding the implementation of such a program. The CPS has been grappling with financial difficulties, having laid off over a thousand educators in recent years and struggling to maintain essential services. With counselors already overwhelmed—some managing caseloads exceeding 400 students—how will they support this new requirement effectively? It seems like a classic case of wishing for a grand outcome without providing the necessary resources to achieve it.
Interestingly, every CPS graduate is guaranteed admission to the City Colleges of Chicago, which offer financial aid for tuition, books, and supplies, provided funding is available. This could increase enrollment in community colleges as part of the new initiative, but given the financial constraints of these institutions, the influx of students could create additional strain.
Critics of the plan, like former CPS teacher Kelly Adams, argue that “a mandate without the necessary investment is merely a political gesture, not a genuine reform.” This sentiment echoes the concerns that the requirement may unfairly target students from lower-income backgrounds, further entrenching existing disparities. As Johnson aptly puts it, this policy seems to aim at a specific demographic while neglecting the real issues at hand.
In conclusion, while Chicago Public Schools’ initiative to require post-graduate plans may have noble intentions, it risks exacerbating existing inequalities and failing to provide the necessary support for all students. As we navigate these complex educational challenges, it’s essential to consider how we can genuinely uplift and empower every student to achieve their dreams.
For those interested in fertility and family planning, you can check out our post on boosting fertility supplements at Make a Mom. Additionally, if you’re looking for resources on pregnancy and home insemination, UCSF’s fertility insurance FAQs provide excellent information. For insights on relief efforts in Louisiana, visit Intracervical Insemination.
Summary
Chicago Public Schools will not issue diplomas to students without post-graduation plans starting with the class of 2020, a move that raises concerns about equity and access, particularly for marginalized students. While the initiative aims to motivate students, critics argue it could exacerbate existing inequalities without the necessary support and resources.